‘Gothic Capitalism: Art Evicted from Heaven and Earth’ by Adam Turl reviewed by Conrad Hamilton


Gothic Capitalism: Art Evicted from Heaven and Earth

Revol Press, Oulu, 2025. 146 pp., $15.99 pb
ISBN 9789526545929

Reviewed by Conrad Hamilton

About the reviewer

Conrad Hamilton is a postdoctoral research fellow at East China Normal University. His works deals …

More

The marriage between Marxism and modern art was, in many ways, always an odd one. Marx and Engels never wrote a treatise on aesthetics; where they did pass comment, they evinced a preference for realism of the Dickensian type over flowery older styles. Due to this, as well as perhaps a diminutive conception of the role of culture as a whole, their immediate successors – when confronted with the more adventurous avant-garde of the late nineteenth and early twentieth century – oscillated between hostility and polite demurral. Rosa Luxemburg, when pressed with her views on the subject, admitted that while she liked some of the German naturalist poets of the 1890s, she found much of what had been produced in the cultural sphere since troublingly solipsistic (Luxemburg 2011: 449-50). More emphatic was Georgi Plekhanov – a figure who did have strong views on aesthetics. The cubists for him were not real artists; they were, as he squarely put it, ‘nonsense cubed.’ This was not an isolated phenomenon: ‘the majority of today’s artists,’ he declared, ‘occupy the bourgeois standpoint and are totally impervious to the great ideas of freedom of our time’ (Hobsbawm 2009).

That imperviousness, which more justly could be said to go two ways, didn’t last. Hoping to capitalize on the rift between avant-gardes and the establishment engendered by the First World War, after 1917 the Bolsheviks initiated a policy of wide sponsorship. This opened the door to an outpour of trailblazing projects – to the unfussy geometry of the Russian constructivists, to the itinerant agit-trains of Proletkult, to the dizzying montages of Dziga Vertov. If these seemed contrary to the more sober spirit of earlier Marxists, so too in a sense was the Russian Revolution – it was, after all, when Marxism discovered it was a culture, capable of defying the diktats of productivism in order to win the world. The only problem? That didn’t work. The Russian Revolution didn’t become a world revolution; its aspiration to global sprawl was given a water burial in the Kampfplatz of Berlin. The Soviet leadership drew the logical conclusion: the revolution, having been contained within a state by its enemies, needed to act like one. This meant, among other things, putting an end to renegade artistic expressions. At Stalin’s behest, the imperious aesthetics of socialist realism – one half Plekhanov, half Hollywood – took their place. The unholy alliance of Marxism and modern art would rear its head elsewhere – with the Surrealists, for instance. But its greatest moment was over.

It attests to the enduring import of the merger of agit-prop and the avant-garde that its influence pervades much of Adam Turl’s new book, Gothic Capitalism: Art Evicted from Heaven and Earth. But Turl is not content, like certain anachronistic art critics, to simply hand-wring against socialist realism. Their target lies elsewhere: not on socialist realism, but on – in a term they borrow from the late Mark Fisher – capitalist realism. Over the past half-century or more, modern art has been increasingly subject to market imperatives. Materially, this corresponds to the drying up of public funding and the extensive financialization of the art market. Ideologically, it corresponds with postmodernism – an ideology that has scavenged the corpus of modern art for formal innovations while eschewing its (admittedly on and off) commitment to the proletarian subject. The result is that avant-gardism finds itself existentially menaced: on one side, by neoliberalism; on the other, by social media and artificial intelligence. To combat this, Turl calls for artists to – following Walter Benjamin – reinvest their works with ‘auric’ significance, engaging anew with politics.

Turl devotes the first section of the book to furnishing the theoretical scaffolding for their project. The idea of the ‘gothic’ is, in its modern form, intimately bound up with a sense of temporal displacement, the fear that the utilitarian logic of capitalism was laying waste to the sacred, including its medieval forms. While often employed to kitsch effect, Turl argues for a theoretical repurposing of the term. By its very nature, capitalism overdevelops some areas and underdevelops others, fusing them into a single, contradictory whole – a process Leon Trotsky referred to as ‘combined and uneven development’. But whereas Trotsky devised this notion principally to explain how Russia begat a revolution in spite of residual backwardness, one of the paradoxes of our neoliberal present is the way that areas have been underdeveloped even in the most seemingly ‘advanced’ nations in the world. This is apparent in the case of many decaying industrial cities, which – beyond the difficulty of their immediate conditions – struggle under the weight of what seems to be a slow cancellation of the future.

Though combined and uneven development has been widely applied within world-systems theory, one needn’t restrict its remit to the interplay between regions. For the foregoing of potential futures is equally apparent within a variety of different non-spatial mediums. The Internet, for instance, seemed in the 1990s as if it could provide respite from the ceaseless circuit of commodification – before turning out, amidst the churning algorithms and paid adverts of Web 2.0, to be just another species of it. Much the same could be said of the avant-garde: that where the works of a Picasso or Rivera once suggested a pathway beyond capitalism, today it has largely abdicated this role. While there may be a temptation to consign these modes of expression to the past, rejecting them entirely in favor of new sites of class antagonism, Turl isn’t persuaded of their political obsoletion. For Louis Althusser, revolution passed by way of ‘overdetermination,’ breaking out not in the most advanced areas, but in those in which contradictions were most diffuse (the Russian Revolution being the archetypal example). In a similar vein, what Turl argues for here is ‘Gothic Marxism’: the idea that, by using art to mine the subconscious of society, imbuing aura to these sites of loss, we can aid in turning them against the dominant capitalist system (a concept derived from China Miéville by way of Margaret Cohen). To support this, he draws on the work of Ernst Fischer – specifically, his vision of the artist as descended from the shamans of primitive communism, capable of channeling the irrational and creating powerful cultural mythologies.

In the second section of the book, Turl sharpens the critique of latter-day art world – as well as hones in on the work of Benjamin. The regnant ideology of late capitalist society has reliably been postmodernism, an approach that denies the existence of the material realm by framing it as in large measure a discursive construct. This has led to predictably bizarre results: Baudrillard for instance claiming  that the Gulf War ‘didn’t happen,’ that it was merely a spectacle manufactured for CNN, as America was slaughtering retreating Iraqis and irradiating the country with depleted uranium. While perhaps not as gratuitous as this, a similar process of depoliticization can be observed within the art world. The conceptual art of the 1960s was, as Lucy Lippard observes, one of the last great attempts to escape capitalist enclosure. In hindsight, however, its main contribution seems to have been to have predicted the financialization of information characteristic of modern algorithms. Much the same could be said of DIY and punk art: while it struggled against the status quo, its eventual migration to the Internet led to its wholesale subsumption by capitalism. This doesn’t mean we can completely take for granted the achievements of these approaches. One of the innovative aspects of punk art, for instance, was the way that – contra the ‘weak images’ of modern art, which often seem tailor-made to hang in the homes of the bourgeoisie – it mixed ‘strong’ and ‘weak’ images, acknowledging the desacralization of the world affected by capitalism while still pitching itself against it. And can this not provide us with a clue for how to negotiate the current conundrum? Faced with capitalism’s high-speed making and unmaking of semi-autonomous cultural spaces, two dominant options have taken hold: to either affirm this process, in the hopes of reaching some ill-defined revolutionary impasse, or to retreat from it in favor of an ethos of authenticity. Yet a careful reading of Benjamin suggests neither is adequate. Politicizing art means ‘politicizing both the auric and mechanically reproduced image’ (69). In terms of revolutionary strategy, this is tantamount to the idea we must address the proletariat as a ‘differentiated totality’: as something uneven, that ‘comes together without sacrificing the subjectivities of its constituent parts’ (170).

While highbrow musings of this type are certainly welcome, one could be forgiven at this point in Gothic Capitalism for feeling that Turl’s theses are altogether too vague. Fortunately, in its third and final section they offer at least a few tangible suggestions for actual artistic practice. To combat the ‘zombie formalism’ characteristic of art today, Turl tells us, its creators must do three things. First, they must generate a narrative of the ‘proletarian subject.’ Second, they must wed this to a ‘metanarrative’ of ‘totalizing systemic change.’ Third, they must recast the art space as a theater, ‘as an ancient spiritual and social platform’ (81-82). To furnish an example of this, Turl turns to – somewhat surprisingly, in light of their professed disdain for ‘Stalinism’ – Bertolt Brecht. The brilliance of Brecht’s ‘Epic Theater’ lies in the way that, by throwing the medium into relief and destabilizing the audience, it was able to bring into view the existence of a politics outside the work in question. Certain latter-day artists have accomplished similar things – the posters of the Black Panthers artist Emory Douglas, for instance, whose ‘combination of mechanically reproduced images with subjective hand-made expressionism mimicked the distancing techniques of Epic Theater’ (85). On the whole, though, the attempts of art in the postmodern era to situate a political ‘outside’ have proven astonishingly barren. ‘Social practice’ art – providing free food for those in need, for instance – simply recapitulates the tenets of bourgeois philanthropy. ‘Outsider art,’ with its fetishization of children and the mentally ill, is paradoxically dependent on the limit that separates art institutions from society as a whole. If nothing else, this tells us that the art world, however haplessly, still longs for something bigger than it is. In a real world where the working class is – like ‘Frankenstein’s monster’ (129) – increasingly augmented by the cynical cybernetic apparatuses of dead labour, that may be hard to see. But to summon it would be to bear witness to something like Edmund Burke’s sublime – a terrible beauty that, by putting the proletariat front and center, makes us feel small.

It’s appropriate Turl ends the book this way, since Gothic Capitalism, for its wide erudition, and conceptual breadth, can easily leave the reader feeling dwarfed. Indeed: Turl has launched an array of cultural projects on the left, and it’s clear that what we have here is the work of an inveterate artist and activist, condensing ideas they’ve accreted over the years into a manifesto that is both learned and urgent. This does not mean it is perfect. Like the uneven proletariat it describes, Gothic Capitalism is the product of conflicting impulses. On one hand, Turl is the unreconstructed romantic, calling upon us to reenchant the derelictions of capitalist development and embrace the ‘irrational’; on the other, they take pains to historicize this tendency, so as to make it fit within the more amorphous framework of dialectics. Yet since dialectics and romantic irrationalism – pace the Frankfurt School – go together like oil and water, this puts them in the position of constantly having to find a trap door with which to escape their own otherwise rigorous temporal schemas. They find it, without too much mediation, in the form of the artist-as-shaman, capable of giving aid to the revolution by channeling the social-spiritual. Yet how plausible is it to imagine that artists – living in spaces far less ‘autonomous’ than those of Fischer’s time – really have this capacity? In 1963, Georg Lukács remarked, in an essay on Benjamin, that those theorists who tried ‘to retrieve an archaic magic culture’ could only do so ‘in the imagination, while in reality they uncritically accepted the capitalist fetishization of human relations into things’ (Lukács 1984: 177). If one accepts this, it doesn’t mean we should turn our back on modern art: if socialists can make productive use of commodity markets, surely they can make productive use of art beholden to commodity fetishism. But it does mean that – with the cornerstone that supports Turl’s defense of the ‘individual artistic tendency’ (27) jettisoned – we would need to take seriously the idea that there is no clear distinction between socialist political art and socialist political control; that, in other words, what appears as artistic spontaneity is in large part the downstream effect of systems that, so far as they have to contend with capitalism, are inevitably coercive. That may sound stultifyingly conservative, like a defense of Stalin, even. But it’s worth considering that a book using the likes of Burke and Heidegger to browbeat political rationalism may not be devoid of a conservative strain itself.

One may get the sense from this that Gothic Capitalism doesn’t rise to heaven but rather sinks to hell. In reality this fracas is unlikely to bother most readers, if for no other reason than that Turl does so many things well here that reproaching one would be a bit like criticizing an accomplished painting for its impossible sightlines. Indeed, if we presuppose that their target audience is the art world, the presence of certain instances of magic individualism may actually enhance the package (something no less true for the questionable sources that subtend it). The rest of us can draw a more quotidian conclusion from Turl’s success – that one doesn’t have to be a shaman to have something to say.

27 December 2025

References

  • Eric Hobsbawm 2009 Socialism and the Avant-Garde, 1880-1914 Libcom.org https://libcom.org/article/socialism-and-avant-garde-1880-1914-eric-hobsbawm
  • Georg Lukács 1984 On Walter Benjamin Foundations of the Frankfurt School of Social Research New York: Routledge.
  • Rosa Luxemburg 2013 Rosa Luxemburg to Sophie Liebknecht, November 24, 1917 The Letters of Rosa Luxemburg London: Verso.

3 comments

  1. Simply, the above review was found an irritant. First and foremost, what is, “the proletariat?” More: “the idea we must address the proletariat as a ‘differentiated totality’: as something uneven, that ‘comes together without sacrificing the subjectivities of its constituent parts.'”

    If “the proletariat”–by my definition–constitutes any and all compelled to work (wage-slavery), is it not self-evident that same-said proletariat is “uneven,” is a “differentiated totality?”

    Interestingly, and according to the reviewer, does the book under review–and, “to combat ‘zombie formalism’ characteristic of art today”–issue three “musts”. [Parenthetically and ironically, does not a “musts” policy tend toward ‘zombie formalism,’ per se?]. While I’ll spare the reader a proper deconstruction of such-said “musts” (i.e., the three desiderata requisite to bludgeon ‘zombie formalism’), I found the possibility of such a programme’s successful implementation more than remote (i.e., chimerical).

    The reviewer discusses, “Frankenstein’s monster”–a reference to the present proletariat–while therewith invoking Burke’s, “Sublime”: “a terrible beauty that, by putting the proletariat front and center, makes us feel small.”

    The aforesaid’s rather ridiculous. “Small?” Nay. ‘Tis pity one feels for the proles. Further, was not Marx’s oeuvre, in its entirety, founded in great measure upon said affect, inclusive of the proletariat’s impotence?

    “…the proletariat triumphs…only by
    abolishing itself….”

    The Poverty of Philosophy

    Further, does the reviewer suggest that–in the reviewed book, proper–the “artist-as-shaman” is something of a quintessence, “capable of giving aid to the revolution by channeling the social-spiritual.” Are not the phenomena (and need) of Shamen, in and of themselves, but symptomatic of human weakness (weakness, e.g., due to the dehumanising folly of the capitalist paradigm, or–historically–ignorance)?

    That said, analagous to a Buddhistic saying, if one were to meet a Shaman on the road, would one not kill said Shaman? As for “magic individualism,” as much principally applies to a well-fed Bourgeois cohort.

  2. There’s currently an exhibition in Vienna on modern gothic art ( https://ateneum.fi/en/exhibitions/gothic-modern/ ).

    The impression I have of a lot of the contemporary radical “leftist” and “progressivist” approach to art is that the artists want to use art as a tool to express and expose how terrible and evil life in bourgeois society actually is. They often want to shock you, deride/condemn hypocrisy, expose evil, ram home a moral message etc. with an in-your-face, pornified and unredeemed extremization of the content.

    I think the problem with this approach is that it’s not the sort of art which most people want to experience. What they do want is art which offers something inspiring, aesthetically pleasing, intellectually refreshing and/or spiritually nourishing. They know very well that there are a lot of things going wrong in the world, the media are full of it. But they don’t really want to take that home, or consume it as entertainment or as a leisure pursuit.

    There’s probably not a lot of money or much of a future in radical leftist art nowadays – except that some rich people who don’t know what to do with their money buy ugly and depressing art for very high prices.

    It has become relatively easy to concoct an artwork these days, but it is another thing to create something that is appreciated by masses of people for hundreds of years or more, or which is unforgettable.

Make a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Secret Link