‘Climate Change as Class War: Building Socialism on a Warming Planet’ by Matthew Huber reviewed by Benjamin Tetler

Reviewed by Benjamin Tetler

About the reviewer

Benjamin Tetler is an independent researcher who works part-time supporting adults with learning …

More

It is one of the defining paradoxes of our age that the more we become aware of the rapidly escalating dangers of human induced climate change, the more we seem incapable of finding any way of diverting ourselves from the path that leads there. The scientific evidence is now so overwhelming that even the professional naysayers have switched tactics and concentrate on downplaying the consequences rather than denying the reality. Yet nothing of any real significance seems to get done. Climate politics appears split into two equally ineffectual wings: on the one hand, global leaders get together at regular summits to set CO2 reduction targets that are then routinely missed, and to endlessly defer decisions over who will shoulder the costs; on the other, direct action campaigns – undertaken by activists prepared to disrupt, such as Extinction Rebellion and Just Stop Oil – are engaged in desperate acts of civil disobedience, accompanied by an increasingly shrill messaging, that are having little traction with a general public who continue to be more concerned, on the face of it, with getting to work on time than they are with planetary meltdown.

Matthew Huber’s Climate Change as Class War is an explicitly Marxist intervention aimed at understanding the nature of this impasse through an unapologetic emphasis upon class. As he says, ‘[w]e need a deeper theory of class to understand who exactly is responsible for the climate crisis’ (17-18). The central claim is that while ‘the real cause of the climate crisis [is] a small minority of owners who control and profit from the production of the energy, food, materials, and infrastructure society needs to function’ (55), the political responses that have arisen to counter it have so far been overwhelmingly middle class in origin and design. As Huber sees it, these strategies  –  heavily focused on the politics of consumption as opposed to production  –  miss the real culprit and focus attention away from genuine solutions. Huber argues that a theory of climate change focused upon who controls and directs production could reorientate itself towards framing working class interests as being compatible with the sweeping changes to society that are necessary if climate disaster is to be averted.

The book is divided into three parts that detail the class nature of climate change. Part I, ‘The Capitalist Class’, delves into the question of who is to blame. One of the problems with the currently fashionable notion of the anthropocene is that by framing climate change as a consequence of humanity in the abstract, it ‘implies all humanity is at fault’ (287). This fails to appreciate that because not everyone is equal within society then not everyone can be held as equally responsible. As such, Huber’s turn to a Marxist class analysis, ‘aims it focus on the capitalist culprits who produce climate change’ (24). While this statement (and others like it) carries the unfortunate result that Huber may appear to want to prosecute a rather crude, class-based blame game, that is not really so. Rather, Huber makes a strong case for understanding capital as social force operating as a blind economic logic within which the role of the capitalist is that of a personification of capital. Huber utilises Marx’s value theory to show ‘how production itself is organized through the logic of capital – and how this abstract logic requires a fundamental indifference to the concrete environmental world’ (81).

Chapter three provides an insightful case study of how one particular industry, the production of nitrogen fertilisers, is driven by capital’s abstract logic to relentlessly pursue profits to the detriment of all else. Huber skilfully deploys Marx’s notion of relative surplus value as a key to understanding the specific importance of the role of fertilisers within the wider context of capitalist accumulation. The replacement of human labour by machines powered by the burning of fossil fuels has been a primary means of reducing costs and improving profits. Carried out within the fertiliser industry, these same logics cheapen not only agricultural inputs directly but also the food produced, and therefore indirectly labour, and the products of labour. A Huber says, this systematic cheapening of goods is the primary dynamic behind increased consumption and its impact on the environment. Yet, while consumption is the main focus of climate politics, its underlying drive ‘in capital’s drive for relative surplus value in the mode of production’ (84) remains outside the purview the professional classes who have so far dominated discourse around it.

Part II, ‘The Professional Class’, sets out how middle class leadership on climate politics obfuscates the problem and compromises its potential for success. While Huber accepts the basic Marxist division of society into two contending classes, he draws upon scholarship that complicates this by recognising that ‘increasing groups of college-educated workers with some degree of autonomy on the job’ (118) have material and ideological differences from workers as classically understood. Huber’s first major point is that the professional class views climate change through the prism of its own particular interests. Functioning for the most part outside of material production, this sphere’s centrality to the problem is therefore overlooked. With its status tied up with the creation and application of knowledge, the professional class views climate change primarily through the lens of science and facts. This leads to its depoliticisation. Tackling climate change becomes a question of firstly believing in the science and then proceeding to find the right technical or policy fix. This ignores the fundamentally political nature of the question of who has power over how and what we need to produce.

The second major problem is that the professional class’s relative affluence within capitalist society leads it to approach climate change, and what needs to be done about it, with a guilty conscience. This has led to a proliferation of ideas about economic degrowth, and schemes for environmental sustainability that emphasise returning to small-scale localised production, and predominantly plant-based diets. As Huber says, ‘[f]rom the standpoint of carbon guilt – wracked by anxiety over excessive lifestyles – a politics of less is intuitively appealing’ (107). Such a politics mimics the austerity imposed upon the working class by neoliberalism and is ultimately unappealing. Cut off from the means of living, the problem for the great majority in society remains securing access to the things they need as opposed to cutting down on them. As such, Huber believes ‘the politics of less is bad strategy’ (173).

Ultimately, Huber’s claim is that middle class hegemony over climate change politics, as it has been constructed so far, deflects attention away from where the real source for an alternative program with a chance of succeeding lies. Thus part III, ‘The Working Class’, argues that a strategy ‘that appeals to [the] everyday material concerns’ (40) of the vast majority of people in society offers the only real hope against global warming. The real problem is not consumption per se but fossil fuel consumption. Huber argues for a Green New Deal – a program of massive investment in moving society away from fossil fuels that can be made to chime with the interests of the working class. The ‘wager [is] that a climate program which appeals to these basic material interests could construct a much wider climate class-consciousness that associates decarbonization with better lives’ (46).

The arguments put forward in this final part of the book are the least convincing. Firstly, advocating for a Green New Deal necessarily presupposes the capitalist logics that have already been uncovered as responsible for runaway climate change in the first place. Moreover, even taken on its own terms, it is not difficult to envisage how within these logics the green side of this new deal will take a sorry second place to the emphasis on the resuscitation of capitalist growth. Under Biden’s stewardship, this is in fact already happening.

There are also problems with the specific strategy that Huber presents to push his vision forward. Singling out the electric industry as the place where decarbonisation must focus its efforts, Huber puts forward a plan for rank-and-file union capture of this key sector. As he says, the ‘electric utility unions could create the conditions to marshal union leadership, resources, money, and organizational power into a national Green New Deal’ (274). While they could, they of course just as well might not. And, given the long history of union politics, the latter would seem the more likely. This relates to a deeper issue. That is, while Huber’s critical analysis of capital undercovers its logics as responsible for global warming his affirmation of a traditional ‘working-class majoritarian politics’ focused on the unions and on ‘taking […] state power’ (201) remains embedded entirely within these logics. The class war he proposes as a solution to climate change is in fact internal to the capitalist logic he has already fingered as the culprit. Likewise, the state he wants to capture and wield as a weapon in labour’s struggle with capital is better understood as the political form that the class struggle takes and not a neutral arbiter set over and above it.

Thus, while the arguments in the first two parts are generally well taken and of fundamental importance for understanding and combatting climate change, the strong emphasis on class as the primary focus of a Marxist critique has unfortunate consequences when it comes to the arguments put forth in the final part. To be fair, Huber’s concluding chapter, which makes the case for a politics of international solidarity, does point beyond the essentially social democratic solution to which his endorsement of the New Green Deal amounts. Yet he does not do enough to allay the qualms raised here that the two halves of his book pull in diverging directions. A theory of climate change based upon Marx’s critique of political economy would have to take seriously the need to move beyond capitalist forms that Huber’s traditional affirmation of the working class continues to presuppose: the state, money and an economy of labour.

5 December 2022

Make a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Secret Link